Syntax 1 Wiki: Week 5: Difference between revisions

From English Grammar
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
(Replaced content with "<font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif"> <font size="3"> <br> <br> Navigation: <div align="center"> '''Main page'''|Syntax_1_Wiki:_Week_1|...")
Tag: Replaced
Line 2: Line 2:
<font size="3">
<font size="3">


== Introduction ==
In the first weeks of this course, we have dealt with the topics:
a. Parts of speech and their features<br>
b. Predicate-argument Structure<br>
c. Feature structures. <br>
This week, we are going to bring these topics together. Remember what the purpose of feature structures like the one below is:
[[File:book-Webelhuth.jpg]]
Feature structures describe an object (represented by the feature structure type in the top-left) by describing the values of the features that are relevant for that object. Thus, for a book we find such features as TITLE and AUTHOR, but not PHONE-NUMBER. The entries in a book catalogue will then presumably all be different, since they describe different books with different properties (= values for features), but the entries are all going to be structured similarly, since each entry describes a book with a feature structure of type ''book''.
Consider now the problem we face when we want to represent what speakers know about the words of their language. For simplicity's sake, we can assume that the speakers have something like a dictionary book in their heads, i.e. a long list of word entries. As in the book example above, the entry for each word will be different from the entries of all other words, but of course words have some features in common that we can capture in a feature structure type ''word''. For instance, every word will have a SYNTACTIC (SYN)<!--PHONOLOGY--> feature whose value specifies <!--the specific word's pronunciation--> the syntactic properties of the word. We are now beginning to define feature structure types for linguistic objects. Of course, as with every feature structure we will make sure that the features we postulate for a particular kind of linguistic object reflect the properties of that object!
Before we define the feature structure type ''word'', it is economical to first define the feature structure type ''sign''. The reason is that all words are signs and therefore words have all the properties of signs. Besides words (N, V, etc.), there is only one other specific type of sign, namely the syntactic phrase (NP, VP, etc.). <span style="color: blue>So, our strategy will be the following:</span>
# <span style="color: blue>We define the most general feature structure type.</span>
# <span style="color: blue>When there are objects that are specific versions of the general type, we define types for them, declare the more specific types as '''subtypes''' of the more general type.</span>
# <span style="color: blue>In the definitions of the subtypes we only specify those features and values that those types have in addition to their super type.</span>
== Feature structures of type ''sign'' ==
So, in accordance with this procedure, we will define the type ''sign'' first. In preparation for this, we will look at a <span style="color: blue>feature structure of type ''sign''</span>:
[[File:Sign_features.PNG]]
Note that this feature structure is of the general format we specified for all feature structures:
# In the top left we find the feature structure type: ''sign''.
# Below the type, we find two rows of the form [FEATURE ''value'']:
<!--* the feature PHON whose value is a feature structure of type ''list'' (of segments or letters)-->
* the feature <!--SYNSEM--> SYN whose value is a feature structure of type <!--''synsem''--> <b>cat</b> (category). The attributes of the feature structure of type <b><i>cat</i></b> are <b>POS</b> (part of speech), <b>SPR</b> (specifier), and <b>COMPS</b> (complements). The POS attribute(feature) has a corresponding value, which is a feature structure of type <b><i>pos</i></b>. The feature structure of type <b><i>pos</i></b> takes also features and values (i.e. the number and type of features depends on the category of the word we are describing). For example, if we are describing a word of category <b><i>v</i></b>(verb), the features(attributes) will be <b>VFORM</b> (verb form) and <b>AUX</b>(auxiliary). The value of the <b>VFORM</b> feature could be a finite or a non-finite (base, presp, perfp) forms. The value of the <b>AUX</b> feature can be either plus <b>+</b> or minus <b>-</b>. The <b>+</b> symbol would mean that the verb we are describing is a modal verb and the minus -- that the verb is not modal. The <b>SPR</b> attribute has a value, which is a list of possible specifiers and the <b>COMPS</b> attribute has a value, which is a list of possible complements.
Since lists and complexes of syntactic<!---semantic--> properties have internal structure (i.e. consist of parts), we describe these objects again in terms of feature structure types that are appropriate for a description of these objects. <!--As it happens, a feature structure of type ''synsem'' contains only one attribute, namely LOC(AL), with corresponding value ''loc''. -->
It is easy to feel overwhelmed by the representation above at first, but don't worry! You will see so many concrete examples of this general structure, that very soon you can draw it in your sleep!
Above, we said that <span style="color: blue>''sign'' has two subtypes, ''word'' and ''phrase''</span>. We will graphically represent that state of affairs as follows. A type that is connected by a line  to another type above it is said to be a <span style="color: blue>subtype</span> of the type above. From the point of view of the higher type we say that it is a <span style="color:blue>supertype</span> of the first type.
[[File:Type-hiearchy-sign-word-phrase.jpg]]
Let us, then, define the two subtypes.
=== Feature Structures of Type ''word'' ===
The definition of the type ''word'' is short. It is simply: ''word''.
This may look funny, because it seems that according to that definition words have no grammatical properties. But remember that an object of type ''t'' has all the properties of all supertypes of ''t''. If ''t'' does not add any features or more specific values of the features to the information in its supertypes, then any object of type ''t'' still has all the properties of all the supertypes of ''t'' '''plus''' the information that it is an object of type ''t''.
Applying this logic to the type ''word'', all words will have feature structures like the following:
[[File:Word_features.PNG]]
Note again that this feature structure differs in only one respect from the feature structure for ''sign'' which we gave above: the new feature structure is of type ''word''. This is the only information contributed by the type ''word'' in addition to the fact that ''word'' is a subtype of ''sign''. Because of this subtype relationship, the feature structure of type ''word'' inherits almost all its information from the feature structure of type ''sign''.
=== Feature Structures of Type ''phrase'' ===
The type ''phrase'':
[[File:Feature-structure-phrase.png | 600px]]
Unlike the type ''word'', the type ''phrase'' adds two FEATURE-''value'' pairs to the information that it inherits from the type ''sign''. The first feature is DTRS (= DAUGHTERS) of type ''list'', which means that phrases may have daughters. For instance, sentences typically have the daughters NP and VP. One of these daughters is more important than all the others and this daughter is called the <span style="color: blue>head daughter</span>. This daughter is described by the feature HEAD-DTR, whose value is of type ''sign''.
=== The Head-Feature Principle (HFP) ===
<i>Phrases and their head daughters have identical parts of speech (POS) features.</i>
[[File:HFP.PNG]]
=== Feature Structures of Type ''phrase'' with Inheritance ===
Feature structures of type ''phrase'' will therefore have the information in the previous representation plus all the information in feature structures of type ''sign''. The reason is of course that ''phrase'' is a subtype of ''sign''. All feature structures of type ''phrase'' must contain all of the following information:
[[File:phrase_features.png]]
If you now compare the filled-in feature structures of types ''word'' and ''phrase'' with each other, you find the following similarities and differences:
Both have the SYN feature<!--s PHON and SYNSEM-->.
''phrase'' in addition has the features DTRS and HEAD-DTR which ''word'' lacks.
Our system of types and subtypes thus encodes that words and phrases have <!--phonological,--> syntactic, <!--and semantic-->information, but that phrases have internal <span style="color: blue>phrase structure</span> which words lack. This difference reflects the fact that words are the smallest unit of syntax and cannot be broken down into smaller syntactic units, whereas phrases must contain at least one other syntactic unit.
== Representing predicate-argument structure in  feature structures ==
In the exercises on Predicate-Argument Structure from Week 1, you were supposed to take a sentence apart into its predicate and 1-3 arguments of the predicate. The quiz software represented this information as follows:
Example: The story amuses the doctor.
Expected answer:
Predicate = '''x amuses y'''<br>
x = The story <br>
y = the doctor<br>
z = -<br>
Go to the [http://141.2.159.95:7003/wt/ Online Grammar] and click on the first main verb in the list on the left, the verb ''amuse''. A little tree with a node V[fin] at the top and '''amuse''' as its daughter should appear. Click on the V-node: now, you see the feature structure of type ''word'' that describes the word '''amuse''' in our grammar. Can you find the information '''x amuses y''' within the feature structure?
-->
<!--
Here is the file that we went through in class this week:
[[File:Valence.pdf|frame|Valence]] <br>
== Homework ==
For each part of speech where the valence may vary from one word to another, find one word for each option and draw a feature structure for it that includes the 3 valence lists. Use the format that you find on the handout! Bring the result to class next time.-->




Revision as of 09:29, 23 November 2020





Navigation:

Retrieved from "https://www.english-linguistics.de/grammarparadise/wiki/index.php?title=Syntax_1_Wiki:_Week_5&oldid=3692"